This article contains spoilers for The Gilded Age Season 4 Episode 3.

One of the benefits, and inevitable drawbacks, of a sprawling ensemble like the one The Gilded Age boasts is that audiences rarely get enough time with every character, whether they are upstairs or downstairs. Previous episodes have struggled to match their pace to this imbalance, but this week’s instalment faces a new problem in the sense that you won’t want it to end. Season 4 Episode 3 balances power struggles between the Old and New Money, enough gossip to sustain audiences for the week ahead, the set-up of new relationships, and a long-awaited wedding, proving once again that eight-episode seasons with roughly 50-minute instalments aren’t nearly enough time to spend with these characters we have come to know and love. The episode comes so close to perfection that its only real flaw is that it isn’t longer.
Much of the episode centres on Peggy (Denée Benton) and William (Jordan Donica), who finally tie the knot in Newport after weeks of preparation. Episode writers Julian Fellowes and Sonja Warfield deliver the series’ finest episode yet, one that makes an undeniable case for the show’s awards potential, provided HBO backs it as it deserves alongside favourite The Pitt. And while comparisons may seem cruel, it’s difficult not to see Peggy and William as everything The Gilded Age wants Marian (Louisa Jacobson) and Larry (Harry Richardson) to be. This includes the differences between their respective families.
Tension between the Scotts and the Kirklands continues, especially when Dorothy (Audra McDonald) and Arthur (John Douglas Thompson) offer the couple wedding gifts and traditions ranging from singers to a broom to step over once they’re wed. Mrs Kirkland (Phylicia Rashad) is less than impressed, refusing to entertain the idea of incorporating such traditions into the ceremony or her church. For the Scotts, however, these gestures celebrate a history they have no intention of leaving behind since they were once denied the right to marry.

The Gilded Age could not have assembled a better group of talent to portray such a storyline, with scenes shifting between Benton, McDonald, and Thompson on one side and Donica, Rashad, and Brian Stokes Mitchell on the other. William refuses to let his mother’s disapproval overshadow his wedding, but it’s Peggy who ultimately takes matters into her own hands. She visits Mrs Kirkland and, through a beautifully written confrontation, makes it clear that she has no intention of spending her marriage proving herself worthy of acceptance. Rather than demanding an apology, Peggy offers her soon-to-be mother-in-law the chance to build a relationship on mutual respect, independent of William, quoting Genesis 2:24. Benton delivers the scene with remarkable composure, and it’s hard to take your eyes off her. It’s also a testament to how far the character has come, and another reminder of how much the series benefits when it gives Benton the material – and screen time – she deserves.
HBO is known for its wedding episodes, but it may very well have outdone itself here. From the exquisite costumes and vibrant colour palette to the goosebump-inducing music and performances, every element combines to create one of the series’ most rewarding sequences. McDonald and Benton are particularly affecting as Dorothy prepares Peggy to walk down the aisle, though Marian delivers the sweetest gesture of all. She gives Peggy the train ticket she bought for her in the show’s first episode as her something old, a token of good luck. Mrs Kirkland’s arrival also offers a welcome resolution to the families’ conflict, though the chemistry between Benton and Donica makes the occasion even more memorable. It would be nice if The Gilded Age left the pair alone, sparing them the turmoil that has plagued the series’ other marriages.
Elsewhere, Agnes (Christine Baranski) fights a losing battle against Bertha (Carrie Coon). Following her less-than-flattering profile in Ladies’ Home Journal, Agnes must contend with the possibility of losing her role as hostess of the upcoming presidential dinner. Baranski is in magnificent form, delivering every expression of disbelief and indignation with impeccable comic timing. Her insistence that vengeance belongs to her rather than the Lord, whom she considers far too lenient, is precisely the sort of dialogue Fellowes and Warfield write so well for her. Cynthia Nixon is equally delightful as Ada, who continues to give her sister as good as she gets, proving right about both the drapes and her desire for a telephone.
One of the impressive things about The Gilded Age is how its seemingly low-stakes social rivalries and plot points can prove far more compelling than its serious storylines. Bertha wastes little time turning Agnes’ misfortune into an opportunity for herself and George (Morgan Spector), with help from Mrs Astor (Donna Murphy). After Bertha secures the chance to host the dinner at the Russell residence, Agnes takes leave of her manners and crosses the street late at night, only to learn that she must fulfil her role as hostess. What might seem ridiculous on paper proves so enthralling that it’s a shame the confrontation doesn’t last longer. Baranski makes Agnes’ humiliation almost unbearable to watch, even as her determination to bring Bertha down remains entertaining. Her wish to wake up in 1881, before anyone had heard of Bertha Russell, is another perfectly delivered reminder of why Baranski remains one of the show’s greatest assets.
But Bertha’s latest social triumph comes at a difficult time for her marriage. George continues to struggle following his use of laudanum, even as he insists that his health is perfectly fine and that his business affairs are the only thing troubling him. His increasingly erratic behaviour leaves Bertha visibly unsettled, as he undermines her at every turn, leaving her desperate to correct wrongs she has little to no power to put right. Her devotion to George is unwavering, though Coon lets the fear beneath it creep through in fleeting expressions and subtle shifts in her stiff composure. It’s a sublime performance, and one that deserves far more recognition.

Meanwhile, Oscar (Blake Ritson) and Enid’s (Kelley Curran) salon brings together an assortment of New York society figures for an evening of art, conversation, and enviable alcoholic beverages. Their guest of honour, unbeknownst to her, is Mrs Fish (Ashlie Atkinson) because she can turn even the smallest piece of gossip into the talk of the town. As with previous seasons, Atkinson continues to steal every scene she appears in, delivering her observations with such gleeful irreverence that it’s difficult not to wish the series would give her more relevance beyond being a gossip and a storyline of her own. By the evening’s end, even Mrs Fish admits that Enid has accomplished something spectacular, laying the groundwork for something that promises to be special.
The salon also gives Oscar a chance to meet Lee Klein (James Scully), introducing the possibility of a new romantic connection, while Jack (Ben Ahlers) makes quite an impression by outbidding Mrs Fish for a painting with Fiona Summers (Maggie Kuntz), Carrie Astor’s (Amy Forsyth) cousin. Even Ada finds herself on the receiving end of some unexpected attention when Dr Harris (Dennis Haysbert) retrieves her dropped purse at the wedding. Their brief subsequent interactions, including Harris looking her way during the vows, are sweet, and the prospect of another romance for Ada after her marriage was cut short is enticing. New York never enacted anti-miscegenation law, but interracial relationships were still taboo, facing significant social prejudice, giving The Gilded Age an opportunity to explore territory rarely covered in period dramas.
The Gilded Age may have once struggled to justify the sheer size of its ensemble, but Season 4 Episode 3 makes the strongest case that the series is on the right path to becoming the peak of compelling television. Given the storylines set up here, if the rest of the season can maintain this standard, the series may finally receive the recognition it has long deserved. Its biggest problem may be how it manages potential vote splitting between Benton, Baranski, and Nixon – and if you’ve watched from the beginning, what a problem to have.





