
Peter Berg’s best-known and acclaimed film is an adaptation of Buzz Bissinger’s Friday Night Lights, which was then expanded into a highly successful television series. It’s only natural that he would want to transpose another novel from Bissinger’s corpus, and one that blends the high-octane, gritty thrills of his war drama with the inspirational feeling of his celebrated sports film. At least, that’s what The Mosquito Bowl sounds like on paper, as Berg and co-screenwriter Mark L. Smith depict the lives of four American college football players – John McLaughry (Nicholas Galitzine), Bob Baumann (Bill Skarsgård), Tony Butkovich (Ray Nicholson), and Dave Schreiner (Tom Francis) – who enlist in the United States Marine Corps following the attack on Pearl Harbor by the Japanese on December 7th, 1941.
Berg’s trademark slow-motion intercuts, with tight close-ups that showcase the bond these soldiers share on the field, are meant to lure us into a film that depicts one of the most harrowing events in World War II history. The newly enlisted Marines will travel to Japan to kill as many “enemies” as possible, which will eventually lead to the Battle of Okinawa, a nightmarish event with some of the highest recorded casualties of the war, which occurred a few months before its end. Berg has the possibility of making a movie that not only reflects on the lives lost during this moment in history, but also, just like his previous historical dramas, reckons with what the Americans did senselessly and barbarically, especially when the atomic bomb was dropped on Hiroshima and Nagasaki.
But there’s no reckoning or emotional reflection in a movie that values shock and exploitation over emotional depth, preferring to plunge the audience into the literal hells of war without any subtlety whatsoever. Like Lone Survivor, Deepwater Horizon, or Patriots Day, the action in The Mosquito Bowl is visceral and direct. Berg and his frequent cinematographic collaborator, Jacques Jouffret, attempt to plunge the audience into the throes of war, but the action quickly feels exaggeratedly cartoonish, especially when the Americans arrive on Japanese soil. There’s a difference, I think, between grounded and exploitative, and Berg doesn’t seem to understand that with a movie like this. Of course, it’s more than respectable to not shy away from the dangers and trauma that a war like this will bring.
Americans have an idealized view of what they think they will accomplish in the war, and how their senseless killing of Japanese soldiers will give them retribution and peace for what occurred at Pearl Harbor. When they’re actively confronted by images they can’t shake, their perception of the war should theoretically change. But there’s no evolution here, no texture given to any of the main cast members. As soon as the action begins, The Mosquito Bowl is a relentless carnage (or gore)-fest with a few moments of reprieve, but never a scene where the filmmaker interrogates what he’s showing, even when soldiers get brutally (and excessively) slain.

I felt unclean watching a movie that refuses, at every single turn, to take a stance on what it’s depicting. To meaningfully engage with its images. To give its American characters some form of three-dimensionality so we can care about them beyond the male-bonding football matches that showcase how close they were. There’s actually a game that gets organized to boost the troops’ morale and motivate them after they lost so many lives in Tarawa.
That should theoretically tell us something about the cost of war, about the human lives lost at a time of pure terror, or of the fact that many of the men shown here never came back home. What do their deaths mean in the grand scheme of events, especially before the atomic bomb was dropped on the Japanese? Berg never asks any of these questions and instead paints the Japanese as ridiculously over-the-top caricatures, replete with the most racist, offensive stereotypes you can think of. Every soldier who doesn’t get their way yells loudly and commits seppuku. Every civilian who looks innocuous is a suicide bomber and blows themselves up with a vest when enough American soldiers are surrounding them. Any actual innocent people decide to throw themselves off a cliff. There’s no nuance to characterize them or even talk about the horrors that the Japanese suffered at the hands of Americans. And they are killed in the most distasteful, torturous fashion.
Of course, the Japanese committed numerous war crimes and atrocities during World War II, but the American response was disproportionate and harmful. Pearl Harbor killed around 2,000 to 3,000 Americans. Okinawa, Hiroshima, and Nagasaki killed a combined 400,000 Japanese. Prior to the end credits, there’s a text that compares the American and Japanese casualties at Okinawa, and the statistics are nothing to be proud of. There’s also nothing to laud about the Americans’ so-called heroism, especially when Berg intercuts what he shot for the film with archival images of the atomic bomb being dropped. What do these images mean in the context of the movie, and what do the sacrifices being shown of the American soldiers actively say when, shortly after, the entire course of world history changed?
It’s a movie that frequently asks questions like these, but refuses to give answers, because they would usually draw hard truths that Berg, a “centrist” masquerading as a conservative, doesn’t want to reckon with. There’s a profoundly grotesque image that occurs after most of Okinawa is completely decimated, with corpses of innocent Japanese being burned and/or filled with blood, where the U.S. troops begin to plant the American flag, which might have been potent if what we previously saw didn’t feel so hateful. It’s only normal that the cinematic retaliation to such senseless racism happened a week later, with Godzilla Minus Zero, which actively reckoned with the human cost of war and mirrored back the events of Hiroshima to the Americans, through the figure of its titular character.

At least that film had something to say about the cycle of violence that war perpetuates. The Mosquito Bowl shows lots of violence and tangible horrors, until they become maximalist cartoons. The action never stays fully grounded, especially when the Japanese are depicted as pure evil that quickly needs to be dispatched and are put together in the same category as the Chinese and Koreans (an actual line spoken by a character in the movie). Perhaps it was of the time, but the racist language being used to even describe them feels unacceptable in a movie that arrives at a time when bridges are being built to never again repeat the errors of the past. In any event, a movie that refuses to even acknowledge the horrors of the war and make the soldiers reckon with their decisions, à la Erich Maria Remarque’s All Quiet on the Western Front, is feckless and cowardly.
None of the actors from its well-mounted cast are particularly good either, least of all Pat McAfee, whose brief appearance as a drill sergeant is unintentionally funnier than any comedy I’ve seen all year. You either try to find new ways to evolve as a filmmaker, especially ten years after the release of your best movie, or become a pure parody of yourself. It doesn’t seem that Berg will meaningfully do the former, which doesn’t bode very well for his Call of Duty adaptation set to hit our screens in two years. Perhaps it will live up to the anticipation or be the most evil movie ever made. I’m betting on the latter, but what do I know?





