REVIEW: ‘The Fall and Rise of Reggie Dinkins’ Season 2 Episode 3 Is Hilariously Sincere

This article contains spoilers for The Fall and Rise of Reggie Dinkins Season 2 Episode 3.

Jalyn Hall and Bobby Moynihan sitting on a couch in The Fall and Rise of Reggie Dinkins Season 2 Episode 3. The text reads REVIEW Season 2 Episode 3.
Jalyn Hall and Bobby Moynihan in The Fall and Rise of Reggie Dinkins © NBC

The Fall and Rise of Reggie Dinkins previously struggled to balance its ensemble within its 21-minute runtime, but Season 2 appears to have ironed out those issues. Admittedly, three episodes hardly offer enough evidence to declare victory, but ‘Hulk Want Candy’ makes a convincing case for the sitcom finding its rhythm. Between Reggie’s (Tracy Morgan) jealousy over Monica’s (Erica Alexander) new relationship, Brina’s (Precious Way) efforts to advance her music career, and Arthur’s (Daniel Radcliffe) increasingly delusional documentary ambitions, the episode delivers one hilarious moment after another without sacrificing any of its characters. It should also come as no surprise, then, that Bobby Moynihan’s Rusty happens to steal the show with his reactions to the unfolding drama. 

Trouble arrives almost immediately when Carmelo (Jalyn Hall) discovers Monica has a boyfriend in the cold open, setting the stage for an episode that leans into the silliness of sitcom misunderstandings. Monica is left with no choice but to gather the family, including Rusty and Arthur, and reveal her boyfriend to be none other than Leslie Purvis (Boris Kodjoe). The name means little to audiences, who haven’t met the mysterious figure yet, but Reggie remembers Leslie as the nerd from their college days. Flashbacks featuring Morgan and Alexander as younger versions of themselves, alongside a child actor playing Leslie, or LP, as everyone calls him, are the first of many comical cutaways this episode, largely because of the obvious lack of effort to lessen the age gap between the three. 

Boris Kodjoe, Tracy Morgan and Erika Alexander in The Fall and Rise of Reggie Dinkins
Boris Kodjoe, Tracy Morgan and Erika Alexander in The Fall and Rise of Reggie Dinkins © Scott Gries/NBC

LP has undergone quite the transformation since college, emerging as an attractive, muscular man who immediately captures everyone’s attention. Monica is not the only one smitten, either, as Rusty and Arthur struggle to hide their attraction. Although Rusty gets relatively little screen time, his limited involvement makes sense, given the episode focuses on Reggie’s feelings about his ex-wife moving on and the changes affecting them all. Nevertheless, Moynihan is such an effortless scene-stealer that he could appear in every minute of an episode and still leave audiences wanting more. He delivers arguably the episode’s funniest line delivery with a perfectly timed “Would. Next question” upon seeing LP.

Arthur, meanwhile, seems equally enamoured with LP and the possibilities his arrival presents for the documentary. He initially welcomes the prospect of introducing new blood to shake up the narrative, after pretentiously explaining plot twists to the camera, only to notice that Leslie could effortlessly pick him up, culminating in a hilarious moment of self-reflection when he asks, “Am I bi?” It’s a brilliant companion to Rusty’s equally unexpected questioning of his sexuality, with Radcliffe and Moynihan making the most of the episode’s droll humour. 

Tracy Morgan and Daniel Radcliffe in The Fall and Rise of Reggie Dinkins
Tracy Morgan and Daniel Radcliffe in The Fall and Rise of Reggie Dinkins © Scott Gries/NBC

That said, it’s Morgan and Radcliffe who benefit most from ‘Hulk Want Candy.’ The episode takes its title from Reggie’s decision to stuff Carmelo’s Hulk Halloween costume beneath his shirt to appear more muscular as he confronts LP. Convinced that Leslie isn’t who he says he is, Reggie launches an investigation that Arthur eagerly welcomes, especially when he realises the potential for a documentary twist. Arthur relishes in the dramatics at first, until their suspicions intensify when they discover that Leslie writes with his left hand in the college flashbacks, whereas the man they have just met uses his right. 

In scenes that best reflect Dumb and Dumber, the two become convinced that LP is actually Curtis, Leslie’s twin brother, although they couldn’t be further from the truth. Curtis is in witness protection, and their meddling ultimately puts both him and a neighbour at risk. Morgan and Radcliffe play off each other brilliantly, reminding audiences which pairing is at the heart of the series despite how well the cast bounce off one another. 

It wouldn’t be an NBC sitcom without comedy favourite Jason Mantzoukas making an appearance. Mantzoukas guest stars as music producer Peter Za, whom Brina fails to recognise as the legend Carmelo believes him to be. Young Thug wants Brina to feature on a new song, but when he fails to show up, she takes matters into her own hands. Encouraged by LP’s advice to pursue what she wants, she films her own music video and impresses Peter in the process. The music is catchy, and the storyline feels like a continuation of Carlock’s work on Girls5eva, the cancelled musical comedy about four women attempting to revive their pop careers after a rapper samples their former hit. It’s a welcome subplot that gives Brina her own moment, and Way certainly delivers, without distracting from the episode’s conflict.  

Precious Way and Jason Mantzoukas in The Fall and Rise of Reggie Dinkins
Precious Way and Jason Mantzoukas in The Fall and Rise of Reggie Dinkins © Scott Gries/NBC

Morgan once again taps into Reggie’s vulnerabilities when Monica and LP confront him and Arthur over their actions. Underneath his jealousy lies a fear of being left behind. Carmelo is heading off to college, Monica has found happiness in a new relationship, and Brina’s career could take her far beyond suburban New Jersey. Arthur will also eventually finish his documentary, leaving Reggie to wonder who will remain in his life. Rusty, however, has no intention of going anywhere. In fact, he admits he’s encouraged everyone to pursue their own interests because he wants Reggie all to himself. 

Ultimately, The Fall and Rise of Reggie Dinkins has struck gold with its ensemble. ‘Hulk Want Candy’ highlights how a sitcom can balance its comedy with light-hearted conflict, allowing each storyline to contribute to a larger exploration of change. Morgan and Radcliffe remain an excellent comedic partnership, and the series is all the better for it, while Moynihan proves that even a handful of scenes can leave a lasting impression. Three episodes into its second season, the sitcom continues to go from strength to strength. 

The Fall and Rise of Reggie Dinkins
Release Date:
January 18, 2026
Network/Studio:
NBC
Director:
Various
Writer:
Various
Cast:
Tracy Morgan, Daniel Radcliffe, Erika Alexander, Bobby Moynihan, Precious Way, and Jalyn Hall.

Leave a Comment

Scroll to Top