REVIEW: ‘Dig’ Strikes Gold With Amy Poehler but Struggles to Find Its Footing

This article contains spoilers for Dig.

Dig key art. The text reads REVIEW.
Dig © Peacock

As network television declined and theatrical comedies faced unforgiving box-office expectations, many comedians who once dominated the screen gradually fell out of favour during the late 2010s and early 2020s. Among them was Amy Poehler, who, after her celebrated run on Saturday Night Live in the 2000s and career-defining performance on Parks and Recreation shortly afterwards, shifted her attention to producing and directing before finding success with her podcast Good Hang with Amy Poehler. The actress makes her long-awaited return to the small screen with Dig, reuniting with longtime collaborator Michael Schur for a comedy that reminds audiences of just how much they’ve missed her, even if her presence outshines the material. 

Poehler and Schur’s creative partnership dates back to their time on SNL together from 2001 to 2004, before they reunited for Parks and Recreation alongside series co-creator Greg Daniels. The mockumentary cemented their knack for character-driven, found-family comedy in workplace settings that border on millennial twee just enough to give their work its own identity. Their latest collaboration swaps the local Parks and Recreation department of Pawnee, Indiana, for an archaeological site in Greece, where an unexpected discovery threatens to upend the lives of four women working on the dig. The two series share little beyond the pair behind them, even if pits in the ground matter to both. 

Amy Poehler in Dig
Amy Poehler in Dig © Colleen Hayes/Peacock

Based on Kate Myers’ novel Excavations, Dig follows Elise (Poehler), an accomplished archaeologist who has spent years working under her mentor, Neville (Hugh Laurie), a renowned professor overseeing the Simantikos site. Despite repeatedly promising to retire and hand over the dig to Elise, Neville remains reluctant to let go of the reins, leaving her stuck in a position she has long since outgrown. Her circumstances become more complicated when Dylan (Geraldine Viswanathan), a former friend who abandoned their plans to establish an excavation of their own five years earlier, unexpectedly returns to Greece. Also working at the site are Clare (Antonia Thomas), the site’s head preservationist whose upbringing has caused friction with Elise, and Patty (Fina Strazza), a sweet but sheltered 19-year-old struggling to find her feet as Neville’s assistant. When the four women unearth a rare artefact, they see an opportunity to change their circumstances, only to find themselves caught up in a long-buried secret. 

While the early episodes take time to establish the characters and their histories, Dig gradually becomes more entertaining as the season progresses, with its picturesque Greek setting offering a welcome dose of escapism. The series builds its overarching plot around an archaeological mystery, but, in true Schur fashion, frequently embraces the silliness of a traditional sitcom, even if it isn’t one. From Elise’s exasperated interactions with the college students spending their summer at the dig to the increasingly absurd situations that arise as the women attempt to hide their discovery, Schur and his team of writers find humour in both the ridiculous and mundane. However, not all jokes land, and making audiences laugh feels like less of a priority later on, a puzzling decision given the lasting popularity of Parks and Recreation more than a decade after its conclusion.

The mystery itself gives Dig enough intrigue to sustain its ten-episode run, especially as the disappearance of the artefact dubbed “Pretty Woman” draws the women into a criminal investigation that isn’t what it seems. Intrigue alone isn’t enough to disguise the series’ inconsistent characterisation of Neville, though, whose role in the unfolding mystery is hard to reconcile with the somewhat affectionate, if frustrating, mentor introduced in the early episodes. Laurie draws on the wit of Gregory House to deliver an enjoyable performance, even if the writing never decides whether Neville’s reluctance to hand Elise the reins stems from his own insecurities – rather than Elise’s perceived shortcomings – or hides a more calculating side to the professor. 

Hugh Laurie in Dig
Hugh Laurie in Dig © Colleen Hayes/Peacock

Instead, the friendships that develop between Elise, Dylan, Clare, and Patty make Dig worth watching. Laurie aside, the wider ensemble is largely forgettable, and the series becomes far more compelling when it brings the four women together. Their contrasting personalities create an enjoyable dynamic, especially as they begin to recognise the similarities beneath their differences. Patty is the unexpected highlight of the four, with her sheltered awkwardness and crush on Elise providing some of the season’s funniest moments. The crush may begin as a running joke sure to generate online discourse, but it soon becomes a sweet exploration of her sexuality that culminates in the teenager finding the confidence to pursue a connection with someone her own age. Strazza brings an infectious earnestness to the role, holding her own alongside industry veterans with a confidence that belies her age. 

For all its charm, Dig is a series of contradictions. Somehow, the Peacock comedy suffers from too few episodes while also spreading itself thin across its ten-episode season. It seems to have much to say and yet says very little where it matters, especially when exploring the professional limitations imposed on women of Elise’s generation and the influence of wealth and privilege in the humanities and academia. Neville’s cartoonish behaviour calls his mentorship into question, raising doubts about how much he has held Elise back professionally. This gives the series a chance to examine the inequalities it seems interested in addressing, but Schur and his fellow writers fail to explore these ideas beyond the grievances they create, treating them more like boxes to tick than themes worthy of sufficient focus in the plot.

Amy Poehler and Geraldine Viswanathan in Dig © Colleen Hayes/Peacock

This extends to the conflicts between its characters. Elise and Dylan’s friendship, for instance, provides much of the series’ initial emotional foundation. Through a series of flashbacks, Dig reveals how Dylan’s sudden departure five years earlier affected Elise’s confidence and willingness to take risks, leaving her reluctant to pursue opportunities beyond Neville’s excavation despite her capabilities. The repeated references to Elise’s avoidant attachment style, paired with her prior reliance on Dylan, even suggest a potentially more interesting romantic storyline than the one the series eventually gives her. Nevertheless, Poehler and Viswanathan’s chemistry makes their reconciliation worth investing in, even if the show resolves their initial conflict too quickly. 

The same can be said of Elise’s resentment toward Clare, whose upper-class upbringing leads her to question the preservationists’ abilities, and Clare’s complicated relationship with her controlling mother. Fortunately, the cast compensates for these shortcomings. Viswanathan’s infectious energy makes Dylan an effective counterpart to Poehler’s more guarded Elise, ensuring that even her most questionable decisions (of which there are plenty) are difficult to hold against her. Thomas brings an endearing vulnerability to Clare, whose apparent confidence masks years of insecurity and a need for approval from those around her. Alongside Strazza, the two establish an easy chemistry with Poehler that makes the quartet’s friendship believable despite their generational differences. Dig is at its most fun when all four share the screen, bringing the light-heartedness you would expect from the people behind Galentine’s Day.

Amy Poehler, Geraldine Viswanathan, Antonia Thomas, and Fina Strazza in Dig
Amy Poehler, Geraldine Viswanathan, Antonia Thomas, and Fina Strazza in Dig © Colleen Hayes/Peacock

Poehler remains the series’ greatest asset, commanding the screen as though she never left. At first, Elise seems deliberately written as the antithesis of Leslie Knope, with her foul mouth, grumpy disposition, guardedness, and apparent inability to inspire the students around her. Where Leslie approached the goings-on of Pawnee with enthusiasm and optimism, Elise meets her surroundings with sarcasm and suspicion. Yet Poehler gradually reveals the gutting vulnerability beneath Elise’s mounting frustration, convincingly portraying a woman whose personal and professional ambitions have repeatedly been thwarted, but who still finds herself on the path to leadership. 

Ultimately, Dig has the ingredients of a much stronger comedy than the one it delivers. Its mystery offers enough intrigue to sustain the season, and its four leading women bring humour and affection to material that doesn’t always do justice to their talents. But inconsistent jokes, rushed reconciliations, indecisive characterisation, and buzzword talking points keep the series from reaching its potential. Still, the series could improve if Parks and Recreation is any guide. Dig has enough potential to suggest a second season could build on what works while swiftly addressing what doesn’t, delivering the comedy about friendship and the frustrations of being overlooked as women that it promised. Whether Peacock gives Schur the opportunity remains to be seen, so for now, Poehler makes the viewing experience worthwhile. After more than a decade away from our screens, her return is welcome, even if the series around her leaves something to be desired.

Dig
Release Date:
November 23, 2026
Network/Studio:
Peacock
Director:
Various
Writer:
Various
Cast:
Amy Poehler, Hugh Laurie, Geraldine Viswanathan, Antonia Thomas and Fina Strazza

Leave a Comment

Scroll to Top