What Should Be Next for the Scarlet Witch in the Comics?
The Scarlet Witch in Sorcerer Supreme #10
Sorcerer Supreme #10 © Marvel Comics

The Scarlet Witch finally has a future in the MCU, which will begin in Avengers: Doomsday. Now, I want to ask the question: what should be next for our favourite crimson witch in the comics?

The Steve Orlando era of Scarlet Witch comics came to a close with Sorcerer Supreme #10 in September, after Wanda uttered the phrase “more magic.” Wanda has now sacrificed her future as the Sorcerer Supreme and disappeared, seemingly gone from the lives of all those who love her. In many ways, Wanda is currently in a position parallel to the one she found herself in after M-Day: hidden from her friends and allies, with no ties to any particular team. Story-wise, Orlando has left the next writer with an almost completely blank slate. Wanda can be anyone. So the question follows: who should she be? While Marvel has yet to ask me for my opinion as a certified Scarlet Witch obsessive, I’m going to give it anyway.

Firstly, I believe that the primary question Marvel needs to answer for Wanda when she makes her next appearance is: what does she want? For so many years after House of M, her primary goal has, of course, been to atone for the suffering she caused and to find a way to reverse the damage she’d done to the world. But she’s done that now. So what are her goals? Her dreams? A lot of modern media outside of the comics surrounding Wanda focuses on her desire for a family. After all, the cause of Disassembled and House of M was the loss of her children. So does Wanda want more children? Does she still dream of a normal life with a partner? I’d like to know. It’s my belief that what draws a lot of people to the Scarlet Witch as a character is not only her immense power, but also her deeply relatable emotional core. People want to see Wanda happy, and I think it’s time Marvel took the time to give her lasting emotional fulfilment in her personal life. MCU synergy would probably lend itself towards a reunion with the Vision, but I think that a new relationship with an existing character could be just as interesting.

Sorcerer Supreme #10 © Marvel Comics

In terms of potential candidates, I’ll start with my least controversial picks and make my way to my most out-there ones. Of course, we have to consider the idea of a reunion with the Vision. We saw them explore the idea of growing old together in last year’s miniseries, The Vision and the Scarlet Witch. But in terms of the comics, it’s been a long time since the two of them actually had a romantic connection, and so, unless a new writer can make a really good argument for a renewed spark, I think it’s time we moved on. I make no secret of the fact that Simon Williams, aka Wonder Man, has always been my preferred Wanda love interest, and with his appearance in the MCU creating renewed interest in the character, perhaps it’s time he and Wanda gave their relationship another shot. I’d even argue it might be an interesting twist to see the two of them start a family together. Vision had Viv and Vin with Virginia, so why can Wanda not also expand her family?

Marvel Rivals has created some romantic tension between Wanda and Venom, but unfortunately, everyone’s favourite ball of black goo seems to be otherwise accounted for with the White Widow. So while I’m always inspired by an unconventional pairing, I think this one is off the table for now. Loki is another fan-favourite pick, with him and Wanda having shared a brief flirtation back in Scarlet Witch #8. I do see the appeal of the two magical users together, but I don’t see him and Wanda managing to have anything particularly long-term. Okay, now stick with me here, because there is one major love interest I’d like to see Wanda re-examine her relationship with, and it’s not who you might think. I think that it would be a gripping and exciting storyline if Marvel revisited Wanda’s time as a bride of Doom.

Now, before you exit out of the article, hear me out. While later comics painted Doom’s motivations as purely selfish, in The Children’s Crusade it’s implied that Wanda lived with Doom for multiple years before she was discovered, and during those years Doom would have had nothing to gain by being with the powerless Wanda. She didn’t remember who she was until Billy arrived, so I believe that Victor must have had some kind of feelings for her to ask her to marry him. I think an epic love story between one of Marvel’s most iconic villains and one of its most popular heroines would be beyond compelling. Whether they simply explore what happened between them in the time she was living in Latveria or write something completely new, it’s something I’d love to read.

Avengers: The Children’s Crusade #7 © Marvel Comics

Another major plot point that I think any Scarlet Witch, or indeed Quicksilver, story needs to tackle is the elephant in the room: who is their father? Back in 2016, it was revealed by their new mother, Natalya Maximoff, that she was murdered by the twins’ father, and since then, it seems as though neither twin has made any moves to investigate further. I’d imagine this is due to the obvious Magneto-shaped cloud that’s still casting a shadow over the two of them. I’m going to say it: give the people what they want and make Magneto their father again. Marvel has the rights again, and all media since the retcon has made him their sort of ‘found family,’ which has never really worked within the context of their backstory. Go on, Marvel, bow to fan pressure and just make Natalya Magda using a different identity, and give back the origin story that everyone enjoys.

My last major recommendation for any future Scarlet Witch writer is to embrace how much her audience enjoyed Agatha All Along and the sisterhood that comes with witchcraft. Much of the supporting cast of Wanda’s previous series has, of course, been made up of her family members, as well as outliers like Darcy Lewis. While MCU Wanda may apparently have no coven, I think a very welcome addition to the Scarlet Witch’s comic history would be for her to form a coven of her own. I think there are some obvious recruits, like Agatha Harkness, the Wu and potentially Jennifer Kale. But we could quickly expand that circle with Magik, Satana, Topaz, Madelyne Pryor and maybe even a reformed Morgan Le Fay. We have, of course, seen Wanda teach at Strange Academy in the past, but having friends and witches of her own age to interact with would, in my opinion, be a very welcome addition to her lore. I think that perhaps a run that included Death’s human form, Rio Vidal from the MCU, would also be gripping for readers.

(L-R) Jennifer Kale (Sasheer Zamata), Teen (Joe Locke), Agatha Harkness (Kathryn Hahn), Alice Wu-Gulliver (Ali Ahn), and Lilia Calderu (Patti LuPone) in Agatha All Along sc© Marvel Television

To summarise, I think that what we need next from any kind of Scarlet Witch solo series is a storyline that can measure up to the iconic status of “No More Mutants.” Currently, that moment overshadows most other plotlines associated with the Scarlet Witch and, in my opinion, it’s not reflective of her character or her appeal. She needs a saga that people talk about, and storylines that are worthy of her now-widespread mainstream appeal.

Leave a Comment

Scroll to Top